The Real McCoy Rum Prices and Buyer’s Guide

There are good bottles of The Real McCoy Rum, and then there are stellar bottles of The Real McCoy alcohol.

This guide will help give you an overview of what The Real McCoy has to offer.

Which bottles cost what? Which bottles are best? Most loved? Most Rare? Most Expensive?

And more.

Later, you’ll find we’ve summarized a short history of the prestigious brand for you so that in 5 minutes, you can pretend to be an expert. 😉

Note: the prices are in US Dollars, and for the US market, if you are outside of the US, the prices may vary. We will, however, include links to the best place to buy your ideal bottle of The Real McCoy in your country.

How much is a bottle of The Real McCoy?

Let’s start by answering the most basic question simply:

The most commonly bought bottle of The Real McCoy is The Real McCoy 12 Year Aged Super Premium Rum which costs around $56-$120.22.

What is the most expensive bottle of The Real McCoy?

The Real McCoy launched its limited-edition bottle, which is the most expensive bottle by the brand. In addition, the Real McCoy launched The Real McCoy Year Prohibition Tradition 12-Year-Old Blended Rumin order to celebrate the 100th anniversary of the pioneer of rum during the prohibition period. It is priced around $102-$140.

Now that you have the simplest answer to the simplest questions, below you’ll find the prices and sizes of the entire range of The Real McCoy Rum, their sizes, prices, and later on, a buyer’s guide.


The Real McCoy Rum Standard Bottles and Prices

The Real McCoy Rum is a brand that offers unadulterated rum with any flavors, sweeteners, or chemical ingredients. The rum is unbeatable in terms of quality. Here are the standard bottles produced by the brand, along with their prices:

1The Real McCoy 12 Year Aged Super Premium Rum$56-$120.22
2The Real McCoy 5 Year Aged Premium Rum$31-$79.99
3The Real McCoy 3 Year Aged Premium Rum$20-$29.99

These were the standard bottles offered by the renowned brand. Read to know about the standard bottle that remains at the top of the list.

The Real McCoy 12 Year Aged Super Premium Rum

The Real McCoy 12 Year Aged Super Premium Rum is considered super-premium because of its smoothness and well-balanced flavors. It delivers aromas of buttery oak, earthy notes, dark chocolate, and even spice on the nose. The finish is quite soft and structured with layers of peppery spice and smoke with butter. The palate receives complex flavored combinations such as caramel, wood, spice, and orange zest. The bottle can be a great rivalry to a fine whisky! The Real McCoy 12 Year Aged Super Premium Rum costs around $56-$120.22.

The Real McCoy Rum Limited Edition Bottles and Prices

The Real McCoy is a brand that produces rum in small batches in order to ensure quality which makes it special. But the brand also produces and comes up with their limited edition bottles which are even more special. Here is the limited edition bottle by The Real McCoy:

The Real McCoy Prohibition Tradition 12-Year-Old Blended Rum

As the name suggests, the Real McCoy Prohibition Tradition 12-Year-Old Blended Rum is a limited edition bottle. It was launched in honor of the 100 Year Anniversary of Bill McCoy’s rum business which became a household name during the Prohibition period in 1920. It has matured and delicate characteristics. One can sense earthy, soft stone fruit, pipe tobacco aromas on the nose. The rum is full of flavors such as honeyed wood, spiced vanilla, and even nutmeg. It has a soft and lingering finish which is often compared with bourbon. Unfortunately, only 6000 bottles of the limited edition were launched.

The Real McCoy Rum Prices and Notes

The Real McCoy Rum has different aromas, textures, and flavors, which have gained global acknowledgment. Here are a few bottles by the brand, along with their prices and notes:

The Real McCoy 5 Year Aged Premium Rum

The Real McCoy 5 Year Aged Premium Rum is said to be older than most of the bourbons out there. It is soft, smooth, and balanced rum with a premium texture. It has aromas of vanilla, fried fruits, brown sugar, and oak. There are different flavors battling with each other on the palate, such as caramel, toasted almond, cinnamon, and bourbon-aged oak, but they are balanced really well. It has a lingering finish with a hint of tobacco and coconut.

  • Size: 750 ml
  • Price: $31-$79.99

The Real McCoy 3 Year Aged Premium Rum

The Real McCoy 3 Year Aged Premium Rum is smooth and soft rum that has gentle notes of wood and spice. One can sense the aromas of bright citrus, vanilla, oak, nutmeg, and some floral notes. It delivers different layers of buttery and toasted caramel, coconut, and marzipan on the palate. The finish is long and buttery with a touch of coconut. It is said that this bottle is older than Anejo tequilas.

  • Size: 750 ml
  • Price: $20-$29.99

About The Real McCoy Rum

The Real McCoy is a brand that produces unadulterated spirits which has no sweeteners, chemicals, additional flavors, or perfumes. It has a brand that was launched as an honor to Bill McCoy. The rum is distilled in a rare combination of copper pots and column stills. It is distilled in small batches, which ensures that the quality remains unbeatable. The rum is aged in the American Oak bourbon casks.

The history behind The Real McCoy Rum

The McCoy has a long history and dates back to the Prohibition Era. The foundation and success of the rum are two-folded. One is set in the prohibition era, while the other is set in the 21st century. Bill McCoy was the person who used to make unadulterated spirit and sell it. He used a rare combination of finest molasses and pure spring water to develop a heavenly spirit during the Prohibition Era. During that time, he and his spirits became a household name. Many tried to copy but could not compete with the quality, and thus it was known as The Real McCoy.

Years later, in the 21st century, Bailey Pryor, who was working to make a documentary on Bill McCoy for public television, the United States brought back The Real McCoy. He is the founder and CEO of The Real McCoy that we know today. Along with the documentary, he came up with the brand to pay honor to the person who came to known as the pioneer of the rum during the prohibition era. Today the brand has gained global appreciation and acknowledgment by winning various awards, and it continues on to run on the path of success.

Why is The Real McCoy Rum so popular?

The Real McCoy managed to gain popularity during the prohibition era, and even today, it has grabbed the limelight. First, the brand is quite popular because of its deep-rooted history. Secondly, the quality of the spirit is worth appreciation as it is unadulterated, and the brand does not use any additional flavors or perfumes. Thus, the essence of the true spirit remains intact. Lastly, the brand has a wide range of variety to offer, which has attracted more people. Thus, everything from history, quality, and variety has helped the brand to gain popularity worldwide.

How to best drink The Real McCoy Rum?

Rum is one such spirit that most people wish to have while relaxing in front of a bonfire. Even the connoisseurs suggest various healthy reasons to have rum in the winters. Rum is surely a winter spirit as it keeps the body warm and has some medicinal properties. But this does not mean that you have to drink it like medicine. There are various ways to consume the spirit, especially if you have rum from The Real McCoy. Here are a few ways to just call out your experimental spirit and try out rum in different ways:


With every sip, you can sip the rum neat and enjoy the true flavors and textures. Just keep the glass in your hand and sip it slowly in the winter season. It will help you understand the real rum, and you will surely have a gala time.

On the rocks or water

If you think sipping the spirit neat is tricky, just add a few ice cubes to your glass. It will not hamper the essence of the spirit, and you can gain pleasure with every sip. Of course, you can also add water instead of ice.


Cocktails are for experimental people who just cannot keep their hands and taste buds away from different flavors. The cocktail hour is when you have a great unadulterated spirit like The Real McCoy. Just try making some great cocktails such as Island Old Fashioned. Just grab rum, John D. Taylor’s Velvet Falernum, sugar syrup, and aromatic bitters. Build it in a glass and then stir in ice. Garnish your drink with orange or lemon peels.

Or you can also try Pucker Up by adding Cranberry-Pomegranate Juice, Beet juice, and fresh lemon juice in a shaker with ice. Just shake the ingredients together. Top it up with tonic water and some citrus peel.

See more in: