The options are endless when you’re looking for the best bottle of Peanut Butter Whiskey.
You’ll find plenty of top shelf options, one more expensive than the next. But what you won’t find a guide to really help you break down and understand which brand of Peanut Butter Whiskey you never knew you wanted.
This is that guide.
Peanut Butter Whiskey might not be your first choice for an on-the-rocks sipper.
But on this list, you’ll find absolutely divine flavors and you will learn to enjoy Peanut Butter Whiskey like you never have before.
And of course, if you prefer a nice cocktail instead, our recommendations will work brilliantly with all your favorite mixes.
Below, you’ll find our list for the top brands in the world and a buyer’s guide to Peanut Butter Whiskey as well as answers to how it’s made and what types are there.
Finally, we’ll round off this article with tips on how to drink and really enjoy Peanut Butter Whiskey as well as the key tasting notes and vocabulary you’ll need to become a true aficionado.
Best Peanut Butter Whiskey Brands to Savor
Here’s a list of the top 5 Peanut Butter Whiskey brands you can buy.
| Rank | Brand | Best for |
| 1 | Hard Truth | Best Overall |
| 2 | Skrewball | Best High-End Option |
| 3 | Sqrrl | Best Value |
| 4 | Sheep Dog | Best for Brand Prestige |
| 5 | Shepherd | Most Easy to Drink |
This is an in-depth explanation of the top Peanut Butter Whiskey brands, including a list of 16 brands and a brief description of their company, products, and popularity.
Skrewball
Skrewball is the most popular brand that first introduced peanut butter whiskey to the market. Founded by Steven and Brittany Yeng, their original peanut butter whiskey became a sensational hit when launched in the United States.
The idea of serving peanut butter mixed with whiskey at his bar as peanut butter whiskey gathered a lot of attention and popularity among alcohol lovers. He teamed up with his wife, Brittany, and developed a standalone peanut butter whiskey spirit that tasted great with cocktails.
They use real ingredients to make a delicious, salty, sweet peanut butter whiskey. It has a medium appearance with warm aromas and flavors of peanuts and honey.
This is a popular and widely recognized brand that is pleasant to drink, reasonably priced, and available in-store and online websites.
Sheep Dog
Sheepdog is among the top peanut butter whiskey brands in the world that make excellent quality peanut butter whiskey. It is made in Louisville, Kentucky. It is the recent addition to the renowned New Orleans-based Sazerac brand.
Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey has a golden appearance with a caramel sweetness along with powerful aromas of maple syrup and buttery popcorn. It also has a nutty flavor with the taste of brown sugar and a vanilla aroma that gives it a perfect balance between sweetness and savory.
It is a well-priced and reputable brand available in many parts of the United States. They do not use real peanuts during the production and opt for natural flavorings.
Sqrrl
Sqrrl Peanut Butter Whiskey is a smooth alcoholic drink, which is great for sipping on its own. It is made in Illinois, the United States. The Japanese spirit giant Beam Suntory produces it.
This peanut butter whiskey has a smooth taste of peanut butter and sweet chocolate, giving the drink a sweet finish with lingering notes of butterscotch and roasted peanuts.
The amber-colored whiskey has the aromas of freshly roasted peanuts and the taste of caramel popcorn. The drink has a syrupy texture with buttery undertones.
This is one of the most reasonably priced peanut butter whiskey brands, with complex flavors in the drink.
Blind Squirrel
The Blind Squirrel is the 3rd best-selling peanut butter whiskey in the world. It is produced by Universal Brands in Princeton, Minnesota, USA.
This caramel-colored peanut butter whiskey has the wonderful aromas of roasted peanuts, vanilla, and cinnamon spice. Its palate has sweet tones of syrup, vanilla, and cinnamon. This drink has a salted peanut taste with a glossy finish and undertones of apple, peanut butter, and spicy cinnamon.
The peanut butter whiskey has an artificial peanut butter flavor, which gives the drinker a syrup consistency.
Ole Smoky
Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Whiskey is blended in Tennessee, one of America’s most reputable whiskey brands. The brand makes 100% corn whiskey, aged two years, and infuses it with peanut butter and other natural flavors to produce peanut butter whiskey.
This caramel-colored whiskey has plenty of natural aromas and flavors, including peanut butter, buttered popcorn, honey, and shortbread. They also use natural peanut oil to give an extra kick to the drink. It provides a smooth finish with a creamy peanut texture and subtle vanilla, oak, and licorice notes.
This is one of the reputable brands that are pricey compared to other peanut butter whiskey brands in the country.
Hard Truth
Hard Truth Distilling is one of the naturally based whiskey brands that make high-quality peanut butter whiskey.
The whiskey has an auburn appearance with powerful caramel, oak, and corn aromas. The brand uses an aged whiskey blended with deep-roasted peanuts to balance sweetness and saltiness perfectly. In addition, it provides a semi-dry finish with a strong peanut butter flavor.
The unusual combination of flavors makes it one of the more expensive and difficult-to-find peanut butter whiskey drinks in the United States.
Skatterbrain
Skatterbrain is one of the popular Canadian whiskey brands that makes rich peanut butter whiskey. Universal Products operates it, a subsidiary of the United States Distilled Products Corporation.
The amber-colored peanut butter whiskey has a hint of sweetness from sugar and peanut butter, which gives a smooth palate with a certain nuttiness. However, it does not have any alcohol burn, so it is best to drink it neat.
Barrell & Banter
Barrel and Banter is one of the popular whiskey brands based in Northern Texas. They use regional grains to distill their spirits, giving their whiskey bottles a unique flavor.
They make their peanut butter version of whiskey using high-quality products. Texas whiskey is blended with peanut butter and natural flavors to balance it and give it the perfect taste and characteristics.
This light, caramel-colored peanut butter whiskey has a semi-sweet taste and a full-mouth feel. It has wonderful notes of peanut butter, toasted oak, and chocolate, along with aromas of cinnamon and vanilla. It is one of the perfect peanut butter whiskies to drink straight with no mixers.
Coastal Creek
Coastal Creek is a private whiskey brand that solely sells its products through total wine & more. It recently released its peanut butter whiskey in 2020.
They use 6-month barrel-aged Kentucky whiskey and blend it with natural peanut butter extract sourced from London and bottled at the Baltimore distillery in Maryland.
Coastal Creek Peanut Butter Whiskey is a bold and flavorful drink with a creamy texture. It is the perfect drink for any peanut butter lover because it has rich notes of peanut butter, molasses, caramel corn, and vanilla that give a warm whiskey finish.
Two Trees
Two Trees Peanut Butter Flavored Whiskey is one of the best-flavored whiskies produced by North Carolina’s Two Trees Distilling Co. The distillery is located deep in the Appalachian Mountains country. It takes years for the alcohol to age in the barrels.
The whiskey is blended with peanut butter flavorings and aged in Appalachian white oak barrels for a rich and smooth taste. This deep brown-colored peanut butter whiskey has rich notes of white oak and peanut butter and aromatic notes of vanilla and brown sugar, which give a pleasant finish to the drink.
Bird Dog
Bird Dog Peanut Butter Flavored Whiskey is crafted using Kentucky Bourbon Whiskey and rich peanut butter flavors. This is one of the best American flavored whiskeys, with aromatic notes of caramel and vanilla that give the drink a warm finish.
The golden, reddish Amber whiskey has a distinct smooth peanut butter flavor with notes of sweet caramel and warm peanuts.
Shepherd
Shepherd’s P Nutty Peanut Butter Whiskey is a Kentucky-based whiskey brand. It is produced by K.D.Distilling Co., owned by the Buffalo Trace Distillery.
The deep brown color of the peanut butter whiskey has sweet and salty flavors witha smooth palate rich in butterscotch and nut flavors. This gives a full, smooth finish with a candy-sweet aftertaste.
This whiskey has natural flavors and caramel colors, which makes it great for sipping with or without ice cubes.
Ram’s Point
Ram’s Point is a Kentucky-based whiskey brand that makes peanut butter whiskey of utmost quality and taste. It is a brand that established its distillery in Maine in 2019.
It is a blended whiskey where peanut butter’s sweet and salty taste is combined with premium whiskey to produce a crowd pleaser. It has wonderful aromas of peanut butter, chocolate, vanilla, and caramel that give a smooth finish with a bit of bitterness at the end.
Copper Still
Copper Still Peanut Butter Flavored Whiskey is a small-batch whiskey that is made with the best ingredients in Arizona. The brand is popular for making hand-selected barrels of Indiana whiskey blended with natural peanut butter flavoring to produce an aromatic and smooth peanut butter whiskey.
This amber-colored peanut butter-flavored whiskey has wonderful aromas of roasted peanuts and a rich taste of honey and vanilla, which gives a soft, balanced finish with a caramel aftertaste.
PB & W
PB & W Peanut Butter Flavored Whiskey is a blend of peanut butter and premium whiskey that most Americans love. It is produced by the Old Elk brand in Colorado, USA.
This handcrafted premium peanut butter whiskey has three different peanut flavors with the perfect creaminess. It has wonderful aromas of vanilla, caramel, hazelnut, and peanut butter chocolate, with a sweet taste of buttered popcorn and chocolate cream that balances well with salty peanuts, which gives a full and sweet mouthfeel.
Ballotin
Ballotin Peanut Butter Whiskey is one of the best peanut butter whiskeys blended with whiskey, peanut butter, and all-natural chocolate to create a classic and sensational drink. It is produced in Texas, the United States.
The caramel-colored whiskey has a smooth texture, which gives a rich finish with peanut butter and chocolate aftertaste.
All About Peanut Butter Whiskey
Here are some FAQs related to Peanut butter whisky:
What is Peanut Butter Whiskey?
A peanut butter whiskey is an alcoholic drink that is made by blending whiskey with peanut butter flavors. It is a 70-proof American whiskey made with peanuts.
Why is Peanut Butter Whiskey So Popular?
Peanut butter whiskey is an unconventional alcoholic drink. It is at the sweeter end, making it quite popular among alcohol lovers. However, it is not as sophisticated as the traditional whiskies, but it is definitely a lifelong favourite for many.
Can You Drink Peanut Butter Whiskey If You’re Allergic to Nuts?
No, it is better to avoid drinking peanut butter whiskies if you are allergic to peanuts and other nuts. Even if the brands do not use real peanuts in the drink, they use nut oils and essences to flavor the drink, which can cause some allergies.
Does Peanut Butter Whiskey Taste Like Real Peanut Butter?
Most whiskey brands claim that their peanut butter whiskey tastes similar to that of real peanut butter. You can definitely get the flavor of peanut butter along with the taste of caramel popcorn.
A typical peanut butter whiskey has both sweetness and saltiness, with a creamy and nutty texture.
Interesting Ways to Consume Peanut Butter Whiskey
Peanut butter whiskey has a naturally nutty flavor, and it’s easily blended with other mixers. You can drink it straight or add a few ice cubes and enjoy it chilled. It is also a great base to make a variety of cocktails, such as
Peanut Butter Apple Cider
Make a nice warm cocktail by mixing peanut butter with hot apple cider and garnishing with a cinnamon stick.
Peanut Butter and Irish Coffee
Give a twist to your coffee by blending peanut butter whiskey with freshly brewed coffee and topping it with whipped cream.
Peanut Butter Milkshake
Make a delicious peanut butter milkshake with banana, ice cream, chocolate, and top it with your favourite peanut butter whiskey to add a kick.
Peanut Butter Martini
Make a fan favorite, the peanut butter Martini, by blending peanut butter whiskey with chocolate liqueur, cocoa cream, and whipped cream. You can garnish it with fresh cream and chocolate syrup.
Peanut Butter Screwdriver
Make a colorful and tangy cocktail by blending peanut butter whiskey with fresh orange juice.
Peanut Butter Old-Fashioned
Make a traditional whiskey cocktail by blending peanut butter whiskey with angostura bitters and topping it with some soda water.
Jelly with Peanut Butter
Make a bright-colored cocktail by blending peanut butter whiskey with cranberry juice and Cointreau.
Peanut Butter Mule
Mix peanut butter whiskey with ginger ale to balance out the sugar content with the bitterness of the ginger beer.
